a peek inside the fishbowl

05 Jan, 2007

Promoting a healthy body image in young girls

Posted by andrea tomkins in: Misc. life

It’s not like we walk around the house in the buff all the time. We aren’t nudists. But we do occasionally travel back and forth between the bathroom and bedroom sans clothing AND we do it without shrieking and grabbing the nearest towel to cover up when a family member approaches.

I am annoyed by people who are hung up about nudity. Everyone is naked under their clothing. What’s to get all uptight about?

Emma loves to tell me ALL ABOUT my jiggly bits. Note the use of the plural “bits” in the previous sentence there. There is more than one area that jiggles, located both north and south of the equator.

I have a carefully crafted reply when she gets on that “mummy is jiggly” bandwagon.

“I love my body,” I tell her. “It’s not big and it’s not small. This is what a normal body looks like.”

She thinks about that, yet never really adds her own comment. The truth is I love my body … most days. On some days I dislike it. But I am getting used to the changes that are happening and trying to deal with it all in my own way.

Are you wondering how we explain overweight people? We don’t. We say that people come in all shapes and sizes and colours, and at our very core we are all the same.

The word “fat” and “diet” are not used around here. I am trying my hardest to keep it that way. I am doing my best to raise two girls so they always love themselves. I want them to know that intelligence, kindness, and generosity are far more important than beauty. And I want them to think they are beautiful the way they are, both inside and out.  

I say thing like:

To Emma: “It’s great to be tall! It’s fun to be tall! Yay for being tall!”

To Sarah:” Curly hair is great! So few people have hair like you do. Yay for curly hair!”

Mark and I both congratulate them both on their smarts and creativity every day.

It sounds simplistic, but they’re still small. I think it’s helped, at least I hope it’s helped. Hair and height are physical attributes they can’t really change. The fat and diet thing is a different story.

I never step on the scale in front of them. I never fuss about my weight (out loud anyway) and as I mentioned, we don’t ever talk about diets. I’m not even sure the girls know what a diet is. But they DO know about exercise, the food groups, and about eating a balanced diet. Food = energy. We tell them their bodies are like cars and that they need the fuel to keep going… and even more importantly, they are growing. We drill it into them repeatedly. If they want to be big and strong they have to eat a healthy variety of food.

What it all boils down to is this: I am afraid that one of them will develop some kind of eating disorder. I don’t want to get into personal history, but I teetered on the verge during high school. Let’s call it Selective Eating. (Mom, don’t call me about this because I truly don’t want to discuss it.)

I blame the media (especially print media) for promoting and perpetuating a “thin is in” mentality. It’s sick, truly disturbing, this obsession the media has with women’s bodies. This is obvious in the Enquirer-type rags that are perfectly arranged at the eye level of a seven-year old girl. One week there is a front page photo about Nicole’s eating disorder, or one of the Olsen twins with their copper-pipelike arms and legs, a blouse slipping off the shoulder reveal something boney and angled and skeletal. The headline screams: she’s too thin! And then the very next week there’s a story about overweight celebrities, or what they “really” look like without makeup, with big arrows and bright circles highlighting the cellulite and Buddha bellies.  Emma knows how to read. And she’s seen those magazines. I’ve asked her to ignore them because they are filled with lies and are only fit to line birdcages.

Emma and Sarah are different kinds of eaters. In simple terms, Emma is choosier but manages to eat a nutritious variety of foods. Sarah has a wider repertoire and enjoys her food more. She has her dislikes (including potatoes, tomato sauce, most cooked vegetables, squash and peanut butter) but loves things like sushi, asparagus and many types of cheese. Neither girl is a huge meat eater. I don’t exactly have a problem with that, but we’ve told them that if they want to become vegetarians they have to ramp up their vegetable intake… and that includes broccoli and beans. So far no one has volunteered to take that extra step.

Sarah, although she’s younger than Emma by two years, has a bigger appetite. This usually translates into an extra cob of corn or spoonful of rice at dinner. We eat pretty well around here. It’s not like she’s getting an extra Big Mac or second piece of cheesecake every night.

Sarah has, of course, has noticed that she likes to eat. She says there’s lots of room in her tummy. We tell her she’s a healthy eater and encourage extra helpings of healthy foods.

You’ll never hear me tell her, neither directly nor by implication, that she better watch what she eats. She’s not overweight, not in the least, but I believe that one comment (even made in jest) could plant that seed of self-loathing – even in a child as young as five.

Some people might disagree with that, but let’s think about it for a moment. Where does an eating disorder begin exactly? I’ve read enough to know that it often begins with seemingly innocuous comments (often from family members) around the dinner table.

“You better watch out,” jokes portly Uncle Drew, pointing his turkey drumstick at the young girl. “You’re going to look just like Auntie Fae if you keep eating like THAT.” He laughs. Auntie Fae gives her husband a swat with her napkin. Crumbs go flying.

“Never mind dear,” she chirps. “You’re bee-youu-tee-ful. Now your uncle on the other hand might want to think about joining the gym this year.”  Everybody laughs, but the damage is done, because the girl has undoubtedly noticed Auntie Fae’s polyester-clad rump spreading over the edges of the dining room chair. The girl shifts uncomfortably in her seat. “No dessert for me,” she says softly, trying to mask the sadness in her voice. 

Get my point? Perhaps you disagree, or have your own story to tell. I would love to hear if you do. In the meantime, we’re just going to continue eating healthy foods (increasing our intake of organics too) and being active. I am happy with the choices we’ve made. I’m not sure if this is all going to help as the girls get older. But that’s something we’ll have to worry about when the time comes.


14 Responses to "Promoting a healthy body image in young girls"

1 | Ciaochow

January 5th, 2007 at 4:49 pm

Avatar

My mom was (and still is) very conscious about her weight and my weight growing up. My parents would tell me I needed to be on a diet or answer for me when someone asked me if I wanted dessert (the answer, for them, was always “no”). When teamed up with teen magazines and pop culture in general, it definitely planted a seed of self-hate. While I would never say I had anorexia or bulimia, I did dabble in both and I snuck my mom’s Dexatrim when I had the opportunity to. There was a striving for perfection – a perfection I could never and have never acheived.

I applaud you for being conscious of raising the girls to have a positive body image. God knows the job will only get harder when the girls are teenagers, but planting these seeds of self-love when they are young is surely going to be of great help!

2 | Janine

January 5th, 2007 at 5:15 pm

Avatar

Good for you, Andrea!

You know, in university I studied eating disorders and discovered that I had a number of traits that those suffering with these disorders often have. (I can’t remember what those traits are anymore.) Anyway, it got me thinking: why do I have a healthy body image, when by all accounts, it looks as if I should have a disorder? And the answer is, my mom was alot like you.

1. We didn’t own a scale. No point, since doctors have one anyway.

2. We seldom ate out, and ate together as a family. We also cooked and washed up together.

3. We got lots of exercise, although I didn’t realize it at the time. We just had fun together, snowshoeing, hiking, swimming, etc.

4. We ignored women’s magazines and tabloids. They were not in our home.

5. I can’t remember my parents ever discussing their weight (or ours) as children.

6. I can’t remember any remarks about my appearance as a child at all. My parents always reinforced what I did, not what I was. I think that’s why I know that whatever life throws at me, I’ll get through it because I can learn how to do things well.

I’m willing to be that your daughters will turn out to be not just beautiful, but healthy, and talented as well.

3 | Miche

January 5th, 2007 at 6:53 pm

Avatar

A very thoughtful post about a very important subject. I think you’ve got a terrific approach that will take your family far.

I hope that I can be that balanced and careful with my family!

4 | Heather Flanagan

January 5th, 2007 at 7:37 pm

Avatar

Thanks for coming to see my vlog!

I love your thoughts and the way you write. On this topic of body image in particular, something I like to do with myself and my body is look in the mirror and imagine that I am 20 years older. Then I tell myself how hot I am and that I would die to have a body like this. Also, I remind myself that I didn’t even appreciate my “too skinny” body when I was young so I better remember to now!

Another quick thought: it is still socially acceptible to make fun of corpulent people. We no longer make fun of different races, sexual orietnations, or developmentally challenged people, but we seem to be OK with making “fat” jokes. This I find disconcerting. ANd I wonder if it because people sub-consciously recognize that, for many people, being fat can be visible evidence of emotional pain on the inside. Ergo, corpulant people are a reminder of our own deep well of pain that we are able to hide. It’s like, “Hey, don’t show everyone your pain, then they might think I have it too.”

Well, I wonder, anyway. Maybe I will vlog on this some day.

Thanks for the great topic!

5 | Sharon

January 5th, 2007 at 10:56 pm

Avatar

YEAH! For you. was was alwys thin when I was younger but now my giggly bits abound and I try to embrace them but exercise is what I lack and I’m working on that. My daughter is thin very thin and we were worried she was on the verge of an eating disorder. We talked endllessly about trying to eat abit more at every meal. ANd she is. Although she is not goaingin much weight she is healthier and you see it in her face.

6 | Sue

January 6th, 2007 at 12:10 am

Avatar

Thanks for this insightful post! Young women (and men) are given such confusing information in the media. It is so great that you’re setting such a healthy tone with your girls.

7 | s@bd

January 6th, 2007 at 12:40 am

Avatar

I love what you’re doing.
And that’s exactly what we’re trying to do over here – model healthy lifestyles AND encourage our kids (although they’re a wee bit young yet) to put good fuel in their bodies so they can be strong and healthy.

8 | Ryan

January 6th, 2007 at 1:06 am

Avatar

How timely. I’m about a third of the way through Food Fight, which is all about food advertising, weight problems, and so forth and am just finishing the section on children. Frankly, I keep thinking of you and your girls as I’m reading it, and your approach to raising them, which you’ve mentioned many times here before (and also in person). I can’t imagine what it’s like to raise children against the bombardment of corporations. And with 2006 being named the year that food was politicized, it’s only going to turn into a bigger quagmire of mixed messages for them.

Eating disorders aren’t limited to girls, either. In university, I used to skip meals to compensate for a lack of exercise, possibly influenced by my mother’s on/off dieting and weight worrying (funny, now every time I come home, she’s trying to ‘put some meat on those bones’). Part of that ‘have to be thinner’ mentality. I think I’ve broken out of that mentality now. Luckily, my parents praised both my brother and I on what we did, not out weight, and encouraged exercise.

I concur with the other commenter(s) – I think you’re going to have some wonderful, self-loving, healthy girls on your hands (or continue to have them). You’re my role model for when I enter that particular challenge in life – kids. :-)

P.S. I see you’re reading Wicked. Yay! Personally, one of my favourites. Hope you enjoy! If you can get ahold of Leaping Beauty, it’s his short story reworkings of classic tales, and they’re all pretty terrific.

9 | Chantal

January 6th, 2007 at 1:10 pm

Avatar

Ditto, ditto, ditto.

Healthy eating is promoted in the girls’ school and they come home and pretty much say “Duh!” to me – because it’s just normal here. Sweets and treats have their place, but otherwise, we eat healthy with some other items in moderation. We are all very active. John and I grew up this way (my Mom was a single Mom and could not afford all the sugary junk and John’s mom was a health nut), so I suppose we’re continuing the cycle we learned.

10 | Claudette

January 6th, 2007 at 1:42 pm

Avatar

This brings back memories of University days living at the dorm and drinking diet coke. YUCK. (That was around the early 90s)

I have this whole thing about Whole Foods and organic choices and live by it as much as is possible. I also wrote about it in my blog. Got some good book recommendations. http://nutty-notes.blogspot.com/2007/01/reading-cookbooks-part-ii-healthy.html

I have a toddler boy and hope to have more kids. But as Ryan above mentions, eating disorders affect all types of people, from both sexes. And it doesn’t have to be bulimia or anorexia, it could be something as simple as almost never eating a fresh piece of produce.

Happy Eating!

11 | Lex

January 8th, 2007 at 4:32 pm

Avatar

Right on! I’m still trying to get my mom to stop pointing out her physical “flaws” because I don’t want to start seeing them in myself.

After watching my mother’s yo-yo dieting, hidding candy on herself, and her anorexia as a teen I made the decision that I would NOT diet. I wasn’t heavy at the time. I’m heavy now and I still stick to the decision not to diet. Even when people give me nasty looks, make cutting remarks and act as if their genetic predisposition to lankiness is more righteous than mine to store energy efficiently.

If I don’t like how much weight I’m carrying I will adjust my exercise and eating and often my food choices. I will continue to believe I’m beautiful for a very long time no matter how many or how few jiggly bits I have at any given time. And due to both luck and good planning my man agrees.

12 | Amy

January 10th, 2007 at 10:41 pm

Avatar

I agree, you have a terrific attitude towards this subject. My mom always made comments about my weight growing up, and as I was a sensitive child and she made them rather publicly, it completely affected how I see myself and others, and how I view lifestyle choices. I have a couple other stories:

My brother and his wife are very healthy, fit people. They eat well and get tons of exercise, and they make sure their kids do too. But when my nephew Jaden was about two or so, my brother noticed that Jaden was eating a lot. He made a comment in front of Jaden that he would get fat. Jaden went around for a couple months after that saying “fat” in a frightened voice, and began picking at his food. Even at that age, kids pick up a lot.

This other story is the kicker, it completely horrifies me every time I think about it. I knew a girl in university whose mother had been put on speed as a child, in order to lose weight, because her parents were so obsessed with body image. She refused to ever make an issue of her children’s weight or eating habits because of that.

13 | Manic Mom

January 16th, 2007 at 6:38 pm

Avatar

Very thought-provoking post. I am guessing you are the anonymous poster and you wrote this to share with me? Regardless, thank you. I have had food/weight/body issues my whole life, and I worry I will unwillingly pass them along to my seven-year-old daughter who is an extremely picky eater.

Thanks though, for commenting at my site, if that was you. You’ve got some nice thoughts over here at quietfish!

14 | andrea

January 16th, 2007 at 7:38 pm

Avatar

Hi Manic Mom – Thanks for your comment. But the anonymous poster on your site was not me. :)

comment form:

Archives

Me and my pet projects

Ottawa Bucket list

Subscribe via email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.


  • Clarence: You could certainly see your skills in the work you write. The sector hopes for more passionate writers like you who are not afraid to mention how
  • Jare: it's a tough job for you. If you need help with moving heavy stuff, we are looking forward to working with you Foosun Moving https://foosunmoving.ca
  • Jare: Your article is helpful. if you're moving out, please contact Foosun Moving https://foosunmoving.ca/
  • Rowyn Tape: Hello, I was sitting at Easter dinner with my grandmother and she was telling me this story. She is Herbert Lytles daughter who eventually bought the
  • goodwrappers.name: Here's a fast failure to know how much to set up a/c in your home.
  • url: If you are going for best contents like me, just visit this site all the time since it gives quality contents, thanks
  • url: I do not even know the way I stopped up here, but I assumed this post was great. I don't recognise who you are but certainly you're going to a wel

The Obligatory Blurb

My name is Andrea and I live in the Westboro area of Ottawa with my husband Mark and our dog Piper who is kind of a big deal on Instagram. We also have two human offspring: Emma (24) and Sarah (22). During the day I work as a writer at the Royal Ottawa Mental Health Centre. I am a longtime Ottawa blogger and I've occupied this little corner of the WWW since 1999. The Fishbowl is my whiteboard, water cooler, and journal, all rolled into one. I'm passionate about healthy living, arts and culture, travel, great gear, good food, and sharing the best of Ottawa. I also love vegetables, photography, gadgets, and great design.

If you'd like to contact me, please use this form. If you're so inclined, you can read more about me here. Thank you for visiting!

 


Connect with me at these places too!

Still calling it Twitter